@Maya Ekron Sure. It's www.futureshiftconsulting.com. However, I contacted support and they told me that it was happening because I was using the "Full Post" layout option for my blog and in that mode they said it's not possible to leave or display comments. Putting aside the fact that that still seems odd to me, I changed my blog to the Postcard layout option. However, in this option when someone clicks on a post and scrolls to the bottom of the text there is no longer any link that says "Write a comment" for them to click on to bring them to the login page. Instead, you have to hope that they see the "Log in to leave a comment" link at the very bottom of the page, but it's not that obvious. The link is below the Recent Posts area and unless they had scrolled to the very bottom of the page to read the post they won't see it. Shouldn't the "Log in to leave a comment" link be right where the comments section normally is? This seems like very poor UX to me. It shouldn't be difficult to see how to leave comments. I have asked a follow up question to the support people to see if it's possible to move the Log in link higher, above the Recent Posts, but I doubt that's possible. This should be improved.

Hi there, I found this thread because I have a related issue. You said that "The login page will pop up the moment a visitor who is not a member will try to like or leave a comment." However, on my site that is true for the Like button, but not for the Comments link. When someone clicks on the comments link under a blog post, it immediately scrolls back up to the top of the page instead of opening the Login window. Presumably, this is to point them to the Login button at the top but it's not obvious, just makes it confusing. It's a real bad UX. I can't seem to find anyway to change that. It should go to the login screen. Any ideas why it's working this way and how I could fix it? Thanks.